Despite pervasive variation in the content of laws, legal theorists and anthropologists have argued that laws share certain abstract features and even speculated that law may be a human universal. In the present report, we evaluate this thesis through an experiment administered in 11 different countries. Are there cross‐cultural principles of law? In a between‐subjects design, participants (N = 3,054) were asked whether there could be laws that violate certain procedural principles (e.g., laws applied retrospectively or unintelligible laws), and also (...) whether there are any such laws. Confirming our preregistered prediction, people reported that such laws cannot exist, but also (paradoxically) that there are such laws. These results document cross‐culturally and –linguistically robust beliefs about the concept of law which defy people's grasp of how legal systems function in practice. (shrink)

In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content:BELSEY ON LANGUAGE AND REALISM by Noel Carroll Like much contemporary literary theory, Catherine Belsey's influential Critical Practice1 is antirealist, where "antirealism" refers both to the rejection of a putative literary style and to the espousal of an epistemological stance, the latter ostensibly grounded in a theory of language, adapted from Ferdinand Saussure. Moreover, these two antirealisms are connected in that stylistic antirealism is, in part, advanced as a (...) consequence of epistemological —or perhaps more aptly "linguistic"— antirealism. Belsey's theory is avowedly political, designed to challenge the operation of ideology in literature, particularly realist literature. That is, though Belsey discusses literature of several different periods and of different genres, her primary preoccupation is with something she calls expressive realism, a tendency perhaps best exemplified by the nineteenth-century novel and still pursued by our less experimental writers. Purportedly, expressive realism is underwritten by at least two tenets: (1) realism insofar as it presumes that literature can accurately represent reality, and (2) a variant of expressionism insofar as it presumes we have access to the thoughts and intentions of authors {CP, p. 7). In this note, I shall concentrate exclusively on the linguistic arguments— which Belsey calls "Post Saussurean" — that are mobilized to discredit the first presumption of literary realism, its claim to represent reality. For Belsey, a major problem with expressive realism is that this sort of literature presents itself or is taken as an accurate reflection of reality. Belsey sometimes makes this point by saying that such literature purports to be an accurate representation of reality. At other moments, that which such literature claims to reflect accurately is said to be experiences of reality. But these alternative claims are also segued by 124 Noel Carroll125 saying that what is reflected are experiences of reality which are recognized to be true. Given the text, the variant of the reflection theory that appears to occupy Belsey most is the notion that literature reflects reality — that is, holds a mirror up to nature, as Hamlet might have it. This raises Belsey's political hackles because she believes that a commitment to the plausibility of the goal of reflecting life accurately invests realist literature with the aura of a socially unmediated, transhistorical, "natural" account of human life rather than an ideologically constructed one. In order to forestall this supposedly political repercussion, Belsey, taking advantage of her expanded version of Saussurean linguistics, charges that realism misconstrues the relationship between literature and the world. Indeed, ana this is the crux of her postSaussurean argument, the error here can be traced to something deeper, viz., a misconstrual of the relation between language and the world, of which the pretensions of literary realism are merely but an instance. Stated baldly, Belsey aspires to debunk literature's claims to realism by denying language's claims to realism. This may seem rather like killing a fly by using a cannon. And, in any case, one would have thought that questions about the representational efficacy of language were logically independent of the issue of the ideological operation of literary realism. However, Belsey, like many contemporary literary theorists, mistakenly believes that one contests literary realism by propounding epistemological reservations about language. Belsey claims that her linguistic antirealism derives from Saussure's putative discovery that "far from providing a set of labels for entities which exist independently in the world, language precedes the existence of independent entities, making the world intelligible by differentiating between concepts" {CP, p. 38). That language always precedes the existence of that to which it refers is a truly astounding discovery. And we should wish to know how Saussure, according to Belsey's interpretation, came upon it. For Saussure, language is a system of signs. Signs are composed of two elements: a material element— a sound-image or graphic image— called a signifier, and a conceptual element, what in different jargons is referred to as a meaning, an intension, or a connotation, and which in Saussure's terminology is called a signified. At this point it pays to notice what is missing in this account, viz., what other theorists sometimes call the reference, extension, or denotation of a term, that is, the set of 126Philosophy and... (shrink)

This text is the introduction to V. Amit & N. B. Salazar, Pacing Mobilities. Timing, Intensity, Tempo & Duration of Human Movements, New York/Oxford, Berghahn, 2020, 202 p. It is also available on Berghahn publisher website.

« Ma Chérie, ceci n'est pas censé être un journal, et il se peut même que ça ne te parvienne jamais, mais j'aime penser à toi en train de le lire, page après page, un jour dans les années à venir, après que je serai partie. J'aimerais t'entendre rire en regardant ces photos de moi. Je suis seule dans ma cabane ce soir et fatiguée ». Avertissement ou défi, ceci est la première lettre écrite par Calamity Jane à sa fille (...) le 25 septembre 1877. Une vingtaine d'autres lettres suivront, de fa.. (shrink)

« Ma Chérie, ceci n'est pas censé être un journal, et il se peut même que ça ne te parvienne jamais, mais j'aime penser à toi en train de le lire, page après page, un jour dans les années à venir, après que je serai partie. J'aimerais t'entendre rire en regardant ces photos de moi. Je suis seule dans ma cabane ce soir et fatiguée ». Avertissement ou défi, ceci est la première lettre écrite par Calamity Jane à sa fille (...) le 25 septembre 1877. Une vingtaine d'autres lettres suivront, de fa... (shrink)

Les treize articles relatifs au premier thème analysent l'émergence ou la diffusion, encore difficile, de l'idée nationale dans l'Italie post unitaire, en particulier à travers la multiplication des statues de Dante, les campagnes militaires, souvent malheureuses, et les liens entre la représentation de la hiérarchie des pouvoirs et des classes sociales, et leur pouvoir politique effectif, à l'occasin de l'Exposition universelle de Milan en 1906. Trois questions sont privilégiées. La n...

Les treize articles relatifs au premier thème analysent l'émergence ou la diffusion, encore difficile, de l'idée nationale dans l'Italie post unitaire, en particulier à travers la multiplication des statues de Dante, les campagnes militaires, souvent malheureuses, et les liens entre la représentation de la hiérarchie des pouvoirs et des classes sociales, et leur pouvoir politique effectif, à l'occasin de l'Exposition universelle de Milan en 1906. Trois questions sont privilégiées. La n...

This article examines whether people share the Gettier intuition (viz. that someone who has a true justified belief that p may nonetheless fail to know that p) in 24 sites, located in 23 countries (counting Hong Kong as a distinct country) and across 17 languages. We also consider the possible influence of gender and personality on this intuition with a very large sample size. Finally, we examine whether the Gettier intuition varies across people as a function of their disposition to (...) engage in “reflective” thinking. (shrink)

This article engages with the vogue for predicting the effects of the Human Rights Act 1998 by focusing on the rape prosecution and trial. The specific interest is feminist scrutiny of the right to a fair trial, particularly the concept of ‘fairness’, in light of the increasing use of disclosure rules (in Canada and England) to gain access to medical and counseling records. Transcending the two contemporary narratives of ‘victims’/women’s rights and defendants’ rights in the criminal justice system, the authors (...) argue for the infusion of the legal debate on disclosure with feminist understandings of wider cultural debates. They suggest that an increased reflexivity about intimacy, publicity and power, leading perhaps to the development of a concept of ‘democratic publicity’ (Fraser, 1997, p. 100), might help to revision the meaning of ‘relevant’ evidence in the rape trial. They also suggest that the wide-ranging cultural debate about memory, truth and history, and the emerging commitment to experimentation in responding to massive, institutionalised human rights violations (including apartheid, war crimes and child abuse) might be of use in deepening current thinking about the rape trial and listening to the ‘voice’ of the complainant. (shrink)

Les treize articles relatifs au premier thème analysent l'émergence ou la diffusion, encore difficile, de l'idée nationale dans l'Italie post unitaire, en particulier à travers la multiplication des statues de Dante, les campagnes militaires, souvent malheureuses, et les liens entre la représentation de la hiérarchie des pouvoirs et des classes sociales, et leur pouvoir politique effectif, à l'occasin de l'Exposition universelle de Milan en 1906. Trois questions sont privilégiées. La n...

Is behavioral integration a necessary feature of belief in folk psychology? Our data from over 5,000 people across 26 samples, spanning 22 countries suggests that it is not. Given the surprising cross-cultural robustness of our findings, we argue that the types of evidence for the ascription of a belief are, at least in some circumstances, lexicographically ordered: assertions are first taken into account, and when an agent sincerely asserts that p, nonlinguistic behavioral evidence is disregarded. In light of this, we (...) take ourselves to have discovered a universal principle governing the ascription of beliefs in folk psychology. (shrink)

Fergus Kelly: Thinking in Threes: The Triad in Early Irish Literature Brian Pullan: Charity and Usury: Jewish and Christian Lending in Renaissance and Early Modern Italy Noel Malcolm: The Crescent and the City of the Sun: Islam and the Renaissance Utopia of Tommaso Campanella H. R. Woudhuysen: The Foundations of Shakespeare's Text J. G. A. Pocock: The Re-Description of Enlightenment Andrew Hadfield: Michael Drayton and the Burden of History Eric Foner: Abraham Lincoln: The Great Emancipator? Gillian Beer: Revenants and Migrants: (...) Hardy, Butler, Woolf and Sebald Stephen Banfield: Scholarship and the Musical: Reclaiming Jerome Kern Brian Simpson: The Rule of Law in International Affairs Christopher Bayly: 'The Nation Within': British India at War 1939-47 John Vickers: Economics for Consumer Policy Gillian Feeley-Harnik: The Geography of Descent Susan Gathercole: Working Memory and Learning During the School Years Lothar Ledderose: Carving Stone Sutras before the World Ends: The Inscription of 1118 CE at Cloud Dwelling Monastery near Beijing. (shrink)

Dernier ouvrage en date de l'excellente série dirigée par Michel Marie de l'Université de Paris III, le livre de Noël Burch et de Geneviève Sellier marque à bien des égards un moment important dans la recherche sur le cinéma en France. Bien que le cinéma de cette période trouble et troublée de l'histoire contemporaine ait déjà été traitée par d'autres (voir Jacques Siclier et François Garçon par exemple), l'approche méthodologique adoptée par les auteurs renouvelle radicalement le disc...

Dernier ouvrage en date de l'excellente série dirigée par Michel Marie de l'Université de Paris III, le livre de Noël Burch et de Geneviève Sellier marque à bien des égards un moment important dans la recherche sur le cinéma en France. Bien que le cinéma de cette période trouble et troublée de l'histoire contemporaine ait déjà été traitée par d'autres (voir Jacques Siclier et François Garçon par exemple), l'approche méthodologique adoptée par les auteurs renouvelle radicalement le disc..

Noël Aujoulat est décédé le 9 janvier 2017. Il avait remis aux Belles Lettres un manuscrit qu’Adrien Lecerf a révisé et complété après sa mort. Ce livre résulte ainsi d’un travail à deux mains indépendantes. Après un avant-propos et une introduction (p. 1-80) sont proposés une traduction des Vers d’or eux-mêmes (p. 81-86), puis de leur Commentaire intégral par Hiéroclès (p. 91-220) ainsi que des extraits de son Traité sur la Providence recueillis par Photios (p. 221-247), des notes sur (...) les de... (shrink)

1 – La première lettre du père Noël et la réponse de Pascal Parmi les lecteurs des Expériences nouvelles, un des moins intéressés ne fut pas le P. Noël, ancien professeur de Descartes au Collège des Jésuites de La Flèche, recteur du Collège de Clermont à Paris, alors dans sa soixante-dixième année. Homme de prudence et de transition, il s’efforçait de concilier les nouveautés du cartésianisme avec les axiomes traditionnels de l’École. La hardiesse avec laquelle Pascal soutenait le (...) vid... (shrink)

Ces deux volumes sont l'œuvre de collaborations multiples et croisées : M. Lamy pour l'introduction, MI. Huille pour la traduction et A. Solignac pour les notes, si l'on en croit la page de garde, bien vite nuancée dans l'Avant-propos qui précise à la fois qu'A. Solignac s'est aussi chargé de la tâche minutieuse et discrète qu'est la révision de la traduction, mais aussi que d'autres collaborateurs sont intervenus : J. Figuet et L. Mellerin. Comme pour les films, les volumes de (...) Sources Chréti.. (shrink)

1 – La première lettre du père Noël et la réponse de Pascal Parmi les lecteurs des Expériences nouvelles, un des moins intéressés ne fut pas le P. Noël, ancien professeur de Descartes au Collège des Jésuites de La Flèche, recteur du Collège de Clermont à Paris, alors dans sa soixante-dixième année. Homme de prudence et de transition, il s’efforçait de concilier les nouveautés du cartésianisme avec les axiomes traditionnels de l’École. La hardiesse avec laquelle Pascal soutenait le (...) vid... (shrink)

L'ouvrage de William Guéraiche s'inscrit dans un renouvellement notable de l'historiographie de ces quelques dernières années. L'après-Deuxième Guerre mondiale, les années cinquante se voient revisitées de multiples façons par les travaux de Noël Burch et Geneviève Sellier, Luc Capdevila, Fabrice Virgili et moi-même. Le découpage chronologique de l'étude ne suit pas les coupures majeures de l'histoire politique française; ni 1958 ni 1968 ne fondent de ruptures, par exemple. La superpos...

Noel Carroll, a central figure in analytic (Anglo-American) philosophy of art, and spouse of renowned dance scholar Sally Banes (who co-authored several of these essays), offers us something remarkable in his new book—namely, a collection of thirty years of his theoretical essays and dance reviews. Carroll wrote some of the pieces while he was a graduate student at the University of Illinois, Chicago, and there have been some dramatic changes since then in both the art world and Carroll’s philosophical views. (...) Thus, he modestly characterizes the book as “an archeological artifact” of a “somewhat confessional” variety (p. 267). Inspired by Carroll, I too will adopt an archeological stance, with a promise that the reader’s patience will be repaid with something surprising at the end of the dig. (shrink)

Scientific realists have suggested that changes in our scientific communities over the course of their history have rendered those communities progressively less vulnerable to the problem of unconcieved alternatives over time. I argue in response not only that the most fundamental historical transformations of the scientific enterprise have generated steadily mounting obstacles to revolutionary, transformative, or unorthodox scientific theorizing, but also that we have substantial independent evidence that the institutional apparatus of contemporary scientific inquiry fosters an exceedingly and increasingly theoretically (...) conservative form of that inquiry. I conclude that contemporary scientific communities are actually more vulnerable to the problem of unconceived alternatives than their historical predecessors, and I briefly suggest how we might seek to pursue scientific inquiry in a less theoretically conservative way. (shrink)